What was to be the Metrodome finale on Sunday, Oct. 4, was a long-anticipated trip from Chicago to Minneapolis for this writer. It was the game played two days later that I never could have foreseen during the summer months, a game that for drama and intensity, tops every one of the hundreds of baseball games I’ve witnessed live.
Not that Game No. 163 was a disappointment. For much of the summer, it loomed as nothing more than a farewell ceremony featuring the Twins from the 1987 and 1991 World Series champions.
It wasn’t until the season was down to its final seven days that the Sunday finale had a realistic chance to be relevant. By then, the Twins had endured a 4-12 slump at the start of August, a stretch in which the rotation generously posted a 7.33 ERA. Minnesota fell seven games back of the Tigers on Sept. 6, and overtaking the first-place Tigers seemed even less likely when Justin Morneau was lost for the season six days later.
Michael Cuddyer and several less-heralded Twins made up for the lost run production. Rookie starter Brian Duensing spun three scoreless outings in September, the pitching was markedly better, and the Twins closed with a 17-4 surge despite missing their slugging first baseman.
The final week began with a four-game set with the Tigers in Detroit. The Twins won the series opener and closed the gap to a single game, but a series split left them two games back with just three to play against the Royals. The final Metrodome contest loomed as little more than pomp and circumstance once again.
The Twins took care of business in the first two games of the weekend series, and the AL Central race was deadlocked after the White Sox beat the Tigers for a second time on Saturday. The long-anticipated Metrodome finale became the biggest game of the season.
To close out a week of virtual Game 7s, the Twins won convincingly on Sunday. Jason Kubel stroked a pair of three-run homers and Delmon Young added two solo shots in a 13-4 win that forced Tuesday’s tiebreaker.
Only for a brief moment was Sunday’s contest in question. The Twins jumped out to a 7-0 lead in the first three frames, but the Royals’ three-run sixth inning closed the gap to 8-4. The rally ended with the bases loaded and the potential tying run at the plate after Jon Rauch took over as Minnesota’s fourth pitcher of the inning. He caught Kansas City’s best hitter, Billy Butler, looking at a called third strike to end the threat. The Twins scored in each of the final four innings to put another must-win away.
The Detroit-Minnesota tiebreaker game, moved to Tuesday with the Packers and Vikings and a guy name Favre occupying the Metrodome on Monday night, was one to remember. It was one of those classics, stuffed with dramatic twists and turns, and game-changing situations that were a matter of inches from going the other way.
It might not have looked that way early on, as the Tigers jumped out to a 3-0 lead in the third inning, thanks to an RBI single by Magglio Ordonez and a two-run homer off Scott Baker by Miguel Cabrera. The Twins closed the gap with a run in their half of the third, and pulled to within a run when Jason Kubel launched his third homer in two games with two outs in the bottom of the sixth.
The Tigers threatened in the top of the seventh, when the Twins used four pitchers to keep the game a one-run affair. A bloop base hit by Detroit’s Curtis Granderson put runners on first and third with two outs, but right-hander Matt Guerrier relieved Jose Mijares and induced an inning-ending grounder from Placido Polanco.
In Minnesota’s half of the seventh, Nick Punto led off with a single, and the Twins jumped in front for the first time in the game when Orlando Cabrera connected on reliever Zach Miner’s first pitch and drove it over the wall in left for a home run.
The Metrodome was as noisy as it had been all day when the Twins took that 4-3 lead, though it took only minutes for Magglio Ordonez to silence the crowd and suck the life out of the building. After the Twins were retired, Ordonez opened the eighth with a home run off Guerrier to make it 4-4.
The Twins had been six outs from a postseason berth. The game’s dramatic shift heightened the intensity, magnified the intrigue. The game seemed to hinge on every pitch, and a host of close calls, misplays and clutch plays made it an unforgettable experience.
The Tigers threatened to take the lead first. In the top of the ninth, Detroit shortstop Ramon Santiago dragged a bunt down the first-base line for a hit, and the Tigers had men on the corners when Granderson followed with a single to right off Twins closer Joe Nathan.
Now the Twins were on the verge of being three outs from elimination, but Nathan struck out Polanco for the first out of Detroit’s ninth. The next batter, Ordonez, lined a shot at shortstop Cabrera, who turned a double play with a bullet to first baseman Michael Cuddyer to retire Granderson. In a manic sprint, the excitable Cabrera high-stepped his way to the Minnesota dugout.
After the Twins threatened but failed to score in their half of the ninth, the Tigers pushed across a run in the 10th. The trouble started when Twins reliever Jesse Crain struck pinch-hitter Aubrey Huff with an 0-2 pitch with one out. Crain bounced back to fan Ryan Raburn for the second out, but a double to left field by Inge scored pinch-runner Don Kelly on a close play at the plate.
The Twins were right back in it when Tigers left fielder Rayburn made a questionable decision to leave his feet in pursuit of Michael Cuddyer’s sinking liner leading off the bottom of the 10th. Rayburn’s slide came up short, and taking the ball on a bounce would have kept Cuddyer from motoring around to third while Granderson chased down the leadoff triple.
After Delmon Young was retired, Tigers closer Fernando Rodney walked Brendan Harris to put runners on the corners. Third baseman Matt Tolbert, a key player in Minnesota’s late-season surge, bounced a ball up the middle on an 0-2 count. It was within inches of being a possible season-ending double play, but the ball scooted past second baseman Polanco and scored Cuddyer from third.
The game was tied again, and Alexi Casilla, who pinch-ran for Harris, had sprinted into third with the possible game-winning run. Casilla would figure in two key moments of the game, and the first might have made him the goat if the Twins had lost.
When Nick Punto hit a shallow fly to left field, Casilla should have been posted on third base. If the ball drops in, he scores anyway. If the ball is caught, the speedy Casilla is ready to tag up. When Rayburn made the catch, Casilla was moving back into third base with his momentum heading in the wrong direction. Rayburn, with a strong throw home, retired the sliding Casilla on another close play.
In the top of the 12th with the score still tied at five, the Tigers loaded the bases with one out against Bobby Keppel, a 26-year-old right-hander with little history of success in the majors or high minors. The Twins had burned through their bullpen in the seventh inning, when they trailed 3-2 and were desperate to keep the Tigers from building on their lead. Now they were in a 12th-inning jam with their eighth pitcher of the night on the mound.
After intentionally walking Rayburn to fill the bases, Keppel delivered an inside pitch that forced Brandon Inge off the plate. The Tigers third baseman immediately turned to plate umpire Randy Marsh and insisted the pitch had brushed his jersey. In another possible game-changing situation that came down to an inch or two, Marsh said Inge had not been hit by the pitch and the score remained tied.
Then Inge hit a chopper over the mound that was a long shot to be an inning-ending double play. Second baseman Nick Punto raced to intercept the ball behind the mound, and while on the run, rifled an accurate, on-line throw that barely beat Miguel Cabrera to the plate for the second out. The threat was snuffed out when Keppel struck out Tigers catcher Gerald Laird on a 3-2 pitch after a lengthy battle.
Carlos Gomez, who had been a defensive replacement for Kubel in the eighth inning, led off the bottom of the 12th with a single off Rodney. Detroit’s closer was pitching in his fourth inning, having entered the game with one out in the Twins’ ninth. The fleet-footed Gomez advanced to second base on Cuddyer’s groundball to Inge at third, putting the potential go-ahead run in scoring position with one out.
Up stepped Casilla, who had lost the starting second-base job after a horrendous start this spring and then spent two lengthy stints in the minors. He was the most unlikely of heroes on a team winning with a number of utility types executing key roles, but Casilla squeezed a hit between the infielders on the right side, sending Gomez around third with the winning run.
The Minnesota dugout emptied and the celebration descended on Gomez at the plate, then headed for Casilla in the middle of the infield. The swarm floated toward third base, where the expressive and fun-loving Gomez could be seen lying on his back briefly at the bag, knees up and hands on his head as if he didn’t believe what had just happened.
The Twins had won their fourth straight elimination game to claim the American League Central crown. They became the first team since the start of divisional play to overcome a three-game deficit with four days left in the regular season.
It was one of those sporting events a fan never forgets, a classic game no matter which team won. To have been there was good enough, regardless of the outcome, but in Minnesota, this remarkable game will be forever tied to one of the great finishes in Twins history.